Human intelligence sources in Venezuela and Washington told STRATFOR April 14 that the
Central Intelligence Agency and the U.S. State Department may have been involved separately in
the events that took place in Caracas between April 5 and April 13. If the information is correct,
the reinstatement of President Hugo Chavez less than 48 hours after he was toppled by a
civilian-military coup could have disastrous implications for the Bush administration's policy in
Latin America.
...
Our sources in Venezuela and the United States report that the CIA had knowledge of, and
possibly even supported, the ultra-conservative civilians and military officials who tried
unsuccessfully to hijack interim President Pedro Carmona Estanga's administration. Sources in
Venezuela identified this group as including members of the extremely conservative Catholic
Opus Dei society and military officers loyal to retired Gen. Ruben Rojas, who also is a son-in-law
of former President Rafael Caldera. Caldera, who governed from 1969 to 1973 and from 1994 to
1998, founded the Christian Democratic Copei party.
STRATFOR's sources say this ultra-conservative group planned to launch a coup against the
Chavez regime on Feb. 27, but the action was aborted at the last minute as a result of strong
pressure from the Bush administration, which warned publicly that it would not support or
recognize any undemocratic efforts to oust Chavez.
Separately, STRATFOR's sources report, the State Department was quietly supporting the
moderate center-right civilian-military coalition that sought Chavez's resignation by confronting
his increasingly authoritarian regime with unarmed, peaceful people power. The April 11 protest
by nearly 350,000 Venezuelans was the largest march against any government in Venezuela's
history, and even without violence the momentum likely would have continued building in
subsequent days. U.S. policymakers who supported the civic groups seeking Chavez's departure
believed their numbers eventually would reach a sufficiently large critical mass to force a change
in Chavez's policies or even trigger a regime change.
However, the violence that killed 15 people and injured 350 -- including 157 who suffered gunshot
wounds inflicted by pro-Chavez government security forces and civilian militia members -- united
the previously leaderless and disarticulated center-right opposition and gave moderates in the
armed forces what they perceived as a legitimate reason to oust Chavez immediately. Sources in
this center-right group tell STRATFOR that the videotapes of pro-Chavez gunmen firing
indiscriminately into the front ranks of marching protesters were "more than enough" to legally
justify a regime change.
The conservative civilian-military group timed its coup-within-a -coup perfectly, using Carmona's
swearing-in ceremony as the platform from which to hijack what was supposed to be a moderate
center-right transition government -- a government that would reach out to the moderate left that
is led by former Interior and Justice Minister Luis Miquilena. STRATFOR's sources inside this
group report that 23 members of the president's Fifth Republic Movement block in the National
Assembly had committed late April 11, after the violence, to vote for Chavez's removal from
power.
Additionally, given that Vice President Diosdado Cabello was responsible for organizing and
coordinating the Bolivarian Circles from Miraflores presidential palace, it was felt that he and
other senior Chavez regime officials could have been removed legally from the government with
the help of Miquilena's votes in the National Assembly and his strong influence over the Supreme
Court.
However, Carmona Estanga destroyed that possibility and irreparably fractured the center-right
coalition that named him to the presidency when he announced the dissolution of the National
Assembly, fired the entire Supreme Court and sacked the attorney general, comptroller general
and the public defender, who were appointed by Chavez.
The dissolution of the National Assembly was repudiated unanimously by every political and
civic organization in the country. The powerful Venezuelan Workers Confederation promptly
withdrew its support from Carmona without making any announcements in that regard,
STRATFOR sources said, and the tenuous anti-Chavez coalition within the armed forces
collapsed almost immediately.
Moreover, tensions between the moderate and mainly army faction led by Gen. Efrain Vasquez
Velasco and the ultra-conservatives flared rapidly as the right-wingers, through the new interim
defense minister, sought to break up Vasquez Velasco's base of support within the army by
transferring some his key associates to other commands.
The picture painted by STRATFOR's sources in Venezuela and the United States is of two
parallel U.S. operations that were executed separately by the State Department and CIA. While
the State Department sought discreetly and quasi-officially to support the anti-Chavez
moderates in an effort to build a viable political center, the CIA was at least aware of the
ultra-conservative plot to hijack Carmona's short-lived presidency.
If the sources are correct, the Bush administration's carefully laid plans soon may backfire.